UnrealSP.Org

The premier Unreal single player site


 
     
 

Custom Map Reviews

       
 

Custom Map Reviews

Map Information

Map Title: Escape from the Cathedral
Map Author: Danilo Di Mascio
Reviewed By: Delacroix
Review Score: 12%

Main Review

Cathedrals. Churches. Temples. I love that kind of stuff. So, after I was told of the Escape from the Cathedral map by Danilo Di Mascio, I decided: I. MUST. HAVE. THIS. The premise seemed simple and unoriginal, but at the very least, entertaining so I promptly downloaded the map and installed it. The readme prepared me for ill-written messages, since the story on what is your purpose here is definitely written by someone who's yet to master English. However, I've experienced a nasty shock when I read the first translator message: the level was entirely in ITALIAN! I had to make a translation and after that, I began my adventure and the effect of it is this here review.

Firstly, the build. The level is very short, made of mostly cubes, planks and arches. There are five locations, of which two can be described as decent for a first-time mapper, the rope bridge and the cathedral itself -- the remaining locales, namely the dungeon, the water reservoir room and the corridor are all crude, to say the least. Barely viewable. The texture choice and alignment is no good either: the dungeon's exit and the large room that follows suffer from horrible texture alignment and the button underwater has a default texture on it. What a view for sore eyes... it'll make you want to pluck them out instantly so that you are never forced to watch this abhorrence. Other locales are bearable, but these three cases I mentioned are enough to spoil any fun. Lighting doesn't help too -- it is, to put it blunt, nonsensical. The light sources seem to shine a bit, but where does all the other light come from? Besides, if the dungeon and its surroundings are so richly illumined, why is the cathedral so horribly dark?

Sound-wise, this level won't please anyone either. No ambience to speak of and Seti.umx soon becomes boring. Nothing to see-- err, hear here, move along. No atmosphere. Nix. Nada. Null.

As for technical issues, I saw little: a default texture on a button, the large water reservoir room has some issues with BSP and the level exit has a collision hull big enough to exit the level prematurely should you try rocket-jumping.

Escape from the Cathedral
The nightmarish texture alignment. Don't try this at home, kids.

Let's see what else this level has to offer. The architecture is, as I already stated, bland -- and it feels that way should you consider what's it supposed to represent. The cells have no windows - okay, we're underground, but why aren't there any small bars in the doors? Despite the obvious lack of any source of air, the Nali within one of the cells and the two pupae within the other feel just fine. Also, a truly funny moment: you can open one of the cells from the inside with a pretty clearly visible button. Nonsense. What's the point of a dungeon cell that you may freely exit... but you have trouble to get to because the button to open the cell is underwater and you need to run fast to the cell before it gets locked again! Why are all other cells already open? Why are the translator messages, which are mostly obvious announcements that would be fitting as signs on walls, placed on books? Why does the cathedral have no benches for the worshippers or an altar for religious purposes? Why this, why that... The level just doesn't make ANY sense to speak of.

The storyline is very original... yeah, right. You're a prisoner, like many before you -- captured by Skaarj forces and slated for execution at the hands of a Great Warlord. A Skaarj SCOUT (yeah, you read that right, a scout, so not wielding a Dispersion Pistol, because they don't carry this weapon -- Skaarj Troopers do) entered your cell and you killed him with your bare hands. Is this even possible? Anyway, you grab his DP and the game begins. After a quick summary of the objectives before you, all you get from your trusty translator are messages typical for signs -- so, a book with "Skaarj Dungeon" is lying on the table just next to the cells, a book "Only one torch per person allowed" is lying inside an armory -- with NO torch-like items around, so utter nonsense -- and lastly, a message strikes you out of the blue (no book or sign of any kind for it to be attached to) when you are about to enter the cathedral.

Escape from the Cathedral
A Skaarj Scout with a DP, or a Skaarj Scout killed by a human's bare hands: which is worse?

All right then: mediocre visuals, repetitive, cliched and badly implemented storyline are definitely valid reasons to avoid this map. But perhaps the gameplay is here to save the day? Sadly, no. First, you are to fight in a narrow corridor with almost no way to avoid the Skaarj guards' fury. If you are lucky to survive that, it'll only get easier: further monsters are located in fairly big areas so you can avoid their shots easily and take them down before they get you and finally, the Warlord is too big to move across the cathedral comfortably and will be easy prey. Isn't it supposed to be the other way around, I mean: first it should begin easy and then as you progress through the level, the difficulty should increase -- not the other way around! To top it off, the aforementioned button-door race against time will play on your nerves, I assure you. First, you have to find the button that opens the locked cell with the two pupae, then you'll probably not realize at first that you have to RUN, RUN before the cell is locked again and lastly, you must engage the two pupae in such a cramped room that you'll be lucky to avoid death. No, gameplay is no good at all.

Escape from the Cathedral
The cathedral that isn't a cathedral at all. It just tries to be one... and fails.

Summary

Uninspired architecture, horrible texture tiling, no sound-induced atmosphere, hardly any storyline and gameplay that'll make you regret ever downloading this level. Avoid at all costs.

BUILD (50%) CAST (50%)
Architecture 2 Conceptual Grandness 0
Texturing 3 Story Construction 1
Lighting 1 Story Implementation 0
Sound 0 Gameplay Awe 0
Technical Execution 3 Gameplay Balance 2

Total Score:
12%

Second Opinions

None to date.

Downloads

Download escafca_eng.zip (1,2MB) from UnrealTexture *

* Translation courtesy by Delacroix. TorchFlameFix by Shivaxi recommended for playing on Unreal build 224 and above.

Home